Resources

The Chair Hire: Most pivotal seat in the house?

The role of a VC Talent Partner is wonderfully varied; truly no two days are the same. But spend long enough working with many companies and patterns emerge. The same people puzzles surface again and again, in different sectors, at different stages, with different founders. And you realise that an “aha” moment with one company often holds lessons that apply to many.


That shared learning is one of the most valuable things we can offer. At Octopus Ventures, we work with hundreds of companies, and passing on what we’ve seen work (and not work) helps founders and leaders scale more efficiently and avoid some well-trodden mistakes.


For later stage start-ups in particular, few topics come up as often, or spark as much healthy debate, as hiring a Chair. For many founders, it’s the first time they’ll bring someone into the business whose job is, in part, to hold them to account. That can feel exciting, unnerving, or sometimes like an obligation imposed from outside.


Hiring a Chair is one of the most consequential people decisions a founder will make, and one of the least well understood. Done reluctantly or in a rush, it can feel like a loss of control and add little. Done thoughtfully, it can give a founder a trusted partner, a stronger board, and a business that’s better prepared for everything that comes next.


The founders who get the most out of the role tend to share a mindset: they treat the Chair not as a governance requirement but as a hire, one that deserves the same care, clarity and ambition as any other senior appointment.

It’s an area where we’ve seen first-hand how much difference the right support makes. We recently placed two fantastic Chairs from our own network into companies, saving those founders time, money and a great deal of stress compared with running a search on their own.

Here’s what we continue to learn:

1. Why do you need a Chair?

It sounds like a simple question, but it’s where a lot of the confusion starts. Founders are often clear on what a CFO or a VP Sales should deliver. The Chair role is fuzzier, and if it isn’t defined, it tends to drift.

At its core, a Chair runs the board, not the company. Their job is to make sure the board is doing its job well: that meetings focus on the things that matter, that the right conversations happen (including the uncomfortable ones), that governance is sound, and that the business is set up for the next stage, whether that’s a major funding round, an acquisition or, eventually, a listing.

In practice, the best Chairs we’ve seen also play a role that rarely appears in a job description. They become the CEO’s most trusted sounding board. Leading a scale-up can be lonely and challenging. There are conversations a founder can’t easily have with their team, and some they’d rather not have with their investors first. A good Chair is the person you call when something has gone wrong at 10pm, and who helps you think clearly rather than react.

They’re also an independent voice in the room. As a board grows, with founders, investors and non-executives, views don’t always align perfectly. A Chair who is genuinely independent can broker those conversations and keep everyone focused on what’s best for the company.

2. How can you optimise the CEO-Chair dynamic?

Founders have built something from nothing, and the idea of handing someone the title “Chair” can feel like handing over the keys.


It’s a fair concern, and it’s worth addressing directly rather than skirting around it. The reality is that a Chair’s power is mostly about process and influence, not day-to-day operations. They don’t run your business, set your product roadmap or manage your team. What they do shape is how decisions get made at board level, and that matters.


The CEOs who handle this best do three things.


First, they own the hiring process. The Chair should be someone you chose, not someone who was chosen for you. That means being closely involved in defining the brief, meeting candidates, and having a real say in the final decision.


Second, they prioritise chemistry and trust. The most impressive name on the shortlist is not always the right one. You need someone you’ll be honest with, and who will be honest with you, including when it’s uncomfortable to hear. In order to assess if that chemistry exists, we encourage CEOs to spend time in person with Chair candidates and to work through real-life business puzzles together to see how they collaborate and whether they ‘click’. Third, they agree the rules of engagement upfront. How much time will the Chair commit? How will you work together between board meetings? Where does their remit start and stop? Getting this in writing at the start avoids a lot of friction later. It’s also worth understanding the formal side, such as what your articles of association say about the Chair’s role and voting, so there are no surprises.


Handled well, a Chair shouldn’t reduce a founder’s control so much as strengthen their position. A well-run board with a respected independent Chair gives founders more credibility with investors, not less.

3. Just a tickbox exercise for investors?

Let’s be honest: founders rarely come to us begging for a Chair hire, unless perhaps they’ve experienced first-hand the benefits of working with a great Chair in a previous role. It is more often a learning journey for founders and CEOs to figure out what value a Chair could bring to an organisation and then scoping out what that profile looks like. Seeing it as a tickbox exercise risks missing out on a game changing opportunity.  


There are good reasons investors care about this. As companies grow, the stakes get higher, the board gets more complex, and strong independent governance protects everyone, CEOs and founders included. It also becomes increasingly important to future investors and acquirers, who will look closely at how the company is run.


But we’d argue strongly that if a Chair is hired only to satisfy a requirement, both the founder and the business are missing out. A Chair appointed reluctantly tends to be underused, kept at arm’s length, and brought in only when something’s gone wrong, which is exactly when it’s hardest for them to help.


Our advice to founders is to get ahead of it. Start thinking about the Chair role before anyone asks you to. Ask yourself what the business will need in the next two to three years, what gaps exist on your board, and what kind of person you’d want to call in a crisis. When the search starts from a leader’s ambitions the outcome is almost always better.


Timing matters here too. The best moment to hire a Chair is before you desperately need one. Running a search under pressure, mid-fundraise or mid-crisis, rarely leads to the best match.

4. How do you measure the true value of a Chair?

We are often asked questions by CEOs on how they can best assess the value add of a Chair hire. Unlike a sales hire, there’s no pipeline to track. Value is real, but it’s harder to see.

A few signals we’ve found useful:

The quality of board meetings. Are they spent on strategy and big decisions, or on reading through numbers everyone could have reviewed beforehand? A good Chair raises the level of the conversation.


Who the CEO calls first. If something goes wrong and the Chair is the first person the CEO wants to speak to, that relationship is working.


How the board handles disagreement. Tension on a board isn’t a bad sign. What matters is whether it gets surfaced and resolved constructively, rather than festering.


What doors they open. The right Chair often brings a network that helps with senior hires, customers, partners or future investors.


Readiness for what’s next. Is the company better prepared for its next fundraise, exit or major milestone than it would have been otherwise?


To make this less subjective, we encourage founders to agree a small number of objectives with their Chair when they join, and to check in on them at six and twelve months. An annual board evaluation, even a lightweight one, is also a healthy habit. It gives everyone, including the Chair, a structured moment to reflect on what’s working and what needs to change.


If you’re a founder thinking about this question, or you’ve been through it yourself, I’d love to hear what you’ve learned. And if you’re an experienced Chair who loves working alongside ambitious founders as they scale, we’d love to hear from you too. Leave a comment or drop Jeevs a message at [email protected].

See more blogs